5 Criminally Overlooked Console Games of 2012

by Nathan Misa Featured 21 Comments 40 Votes 17958 Views 17/12/2012 Back to Articles

2012 has been a busy year in gaming, with plenty of high-profile releases -- Diablo III, Mass Effect 3, Halo 4 and the annual CoD and Assassin’s Creed to name a few. But like every year, for each gaming blockbuster, there's a bunch of quiet achievers lost in obscurity. MMGN takes a look at some of the most overlooked video game gems of 2012.

Binary Domain

Released quietly in February of this year and hardly promoted by Sega, Binary Domain deserved better. It fell into obscurity early when its ill-timed release was sandwiched between the massive hype and launch of the Playstation Vita and the release of Mass Effect 3, which dashed its chances of establishing a name for itself.

Binary Domain exactly didn’t bring anything substantially new to the table, but its extremely solid squad-based third-person shooter gameplay, visually stunning graphics and intriguing storyline of a futuristic Japan engulfed by the ethical and moral realities of robotics is something to experience for yourself. The relentless robotic enemies -- from the basic droid foot soldiers to giant mechanical tanks and behemoths -- are an absolute blast to fight, and the unique squad relationship system -- where you could choose which of your quirky teammates to fight with and gain or lose favour with based on your actions and responses -- added an odd but charming element to the shooter gameplay. Binary Domain easily matches Gears of War as an extremely solid and enjoyable third-person shooter experience, and is one that you can’t miss.

MMGN's Review verdict: 7.5

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

Kingdoms of Amalur

Also released in February, Kingdoms of Amalur is an epic fantasy RPG that just didn’t get the attention and praise it deserved. The initial reason was the Skyrim withdrawals (or addictions) everyone was still having, which left other sprawling open-world RPGs out of the question for most gamers. However, the collapse and eventual demise of both 38 Studios and Big Huge Games also hurt the game and sealed its criminally overlooked fate.

Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning certainly wasn't a failure, having sold well enough and scoring high in many reviews -- it just got crowded in a market unfriendly to new IPs. Amalur is an expansive and deep RPG with a colourful art style, solid combat and crazy loot. If you’re after a grand RPG on the scale of Skyrim or Dragon’s Dogma, you would be crazy not to give Amalur a try if you’ve ignored it until this point.

MMGN's Review verdict: 9.0

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

Spec Ops: The Line

In a market crowded with shooters, it is understandable that Spec Ops: The Line would be mostly overlooked or dismissed as another generic title, or overshadowed by the likes of Black Ops II and Halo 4. But what could have been another dude-bro squad shooter was actually something much deeper; an emotionally engaging story about the lasting perils and fickle morality of war.

For it's story, characters and exploration of morality and humanity alone, Spec Ops: The Line deserves a chance over other typical shooters available on the market.

MMGN's Review verdict: 8.0

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

The Walking Dead

Telltale’s episodic The Walking Dead series may be the only game on this list which has finally received the critical acclaim it deserved -- having won the GOTY award at this year’s VGAs-- but it still is a title that is largely overlooked or ignored by the gaming community. It wouldn’t be a stretch to say that many gamers expressed surprise at its win, or even knew what the game was about at all.

The Walking Dead is a prime example of the importance and depth the videogame medium can bring to story-telling. The game's emotionally engaging story, its subtle and wide-reaching reactions to your choices and strong characterisation trumps over any graphical prowess, multiplayer mode or new hardware gimmicks that would have enticed other gamers if Telltale had bowed to mainstream templates, which they thankfully did not. If you haven’t already given the game its due attention, now is the perfect time to do so as the fifth and final (heart-breaking but brilliant) episode was released just last month.

MMGN's Review verdict(s): 8.5 (Episode 1), 8.5 (Episode 2), 7.0 (Episode 3), 9.5. (Episode 5).

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.


After five years in the making, the unique indie puzzle-meets-retro platformer game known as Fez was finally released on Xbox Live Arcade.

With impressive sprite artwork, 2D-3D spinning mechanic and clever puzzles, it's a shame that the title did not receive the major media attention it deserved, though much of its lack of mainstream success has to do with its exclusivity to Xbox Live Arcade and being an indie title -- it's just too hip for most people. But don't let that stop you now that you've heard about it -- it's a gaming experience you won't ever regret.

MMGN's Review verdict: 9.0

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

Other overlooked titles of 2012

Kid Icarus | 3DS

The Darkness II | Multiplatform

Syndicate | Multiplatform

The Last Story | Wii

Deadlight | XBLA, PC

Torchlight II | PC/Indie

HOME | PC/Indie

Lone Survivor | PC/Indie

Click on each for the official MMGN review and verdict.

What are some of the most overlooked or underrated video game gems of 2012 on your list?

Nathan Misa is the senior games writer, reviewer and contributor for MMGN.com and GamesFix, and way too keen on niche games for the sake of it. You can hear his ramblings and thoughts here on MMGN, and Twitter.

Link to us http://PS3.mmgn.com/Articles/5-criminally-overlooked-console-games-of
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

5 Criminally Overlooked Console Games of 2012 Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Vouching for Spec Ops: The Line. Definitely an under-rated game tbh.

It's amazing!!!
+ A million for Spec Ops.

Simple gameplay but EASILY one of the best stories in a game from 2012.
I agree I loved kingdoms of amalur..put over 60 hours into it.

Kid Icarus (2002) | 3DS


Blob said: Kid Icarus (2002) | 3DS

Fixed now, haha I used my coding from my other articles and forgot to change that bit. :P

Also, for clarification; there are plenty of other notable mentions of overlooked titles this year. The 5 I covered are games that I've specifically played through.
Borderlands 2 was overlooked. [MOG] [MOG]
No way Borderlands 2 was overlooked it got so much hype. I also agree with Binary Domain, that was overlooked. Such a great game.

Harriso840 said: No way Borderlands 2 was overlooked it got so much hype. I also agree with Binary Domain, that was overlooked. Such a great game.

Sarcasm is everywhere on this site (also, the internet). In fact I'm half thinking your comment is sarcastic as well...

This list hit some pretty good games I haven't played yet because they've been overlooked... I don't even remember Binary Domain at all! I've also heard Heroes of Ruin (3DS) is a pretty overlooked game as well, but I'm not into Diablo-style games so I'm skipping over it. ;O
The only game on this list that might merit being called 'overlooked' is Binary Domain, and even that might not be an accident, depending on what you read.
Fez has it problems mainly due to how much XBLA charges them to patch the game
No mention of Starhawk makes me sad.
Im vouching for left 4 dead , and also putting zombi u in mine as well , as 007 legends, each of these games were either overshadowed or poorly rated as a result no one gives them the credit they deserve,

zombi u is a awsome horror game about true survival its just you and your croquet stick , and maybe some ammo -but like the original re's you must use it wisely , . and if you die you must locate your survivors body and get all your stuff back besides 11 bullets and your croquet stick ,

and in survival mode only one life and your done
I liked Spec Ops: The Line, Kingdoms of Amalur, and Binary Domain quite a bit. They are at least worth a rent.
I did not like Zombie U at all, hated everything about it, the controls, graphics were garbage, controls were awful.
Binary Domain was pretty good on consoles but pretty shocking on PC. Terrible port.

I guess Starhawk was overlooked, but does anyone really care :P
Dragon's Dogma?
Sleeping Dogs? That game was awesome, and I didn't hear much about it through the year.

Kinda hard to call syndicate underrated when it was banned in aus
Playing Fez right now!
Binary Domain was average...
Kingdoms on the other hand was awesome
kingdoms is singleplayer wow

its a shitsandwich

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured PS3 Content

Most Anticipated October Game

Most Anticipated October Game

28/09/2015 Polls 5 12
The Force Awakens comes to life in Disney Infinity 3.0 trailer

The Force Awakens comes to life in Disney Infinity 3.0 trailer

Gryllis 2 days News 0 2
The AU PlayStation Store is having a Black Friday sale now

The AU PlayStation Store is having a Black Friday sale now

Gryllis 2 days News 4 7
Beyond: Two Souls review

Beyond: Two Souls review

Leigh748 2 days Reviews 20 25
Channel 9 is now in HD, retune your TV

Channel 9 is now in HD, retune your TV

Gryllis 2 days News 13 14
Who do we blame for Dead Or Alive Xtreme 3

Who do we blame for Dead Or Alive Xtreme 3's snub?

Tano 2 days Articles 0 3
PlayStation Plus games confirmed for December 2015

PlayStation Plus games confirmed for December 2015

Gryllis 3 days News 4 5
PlayStation 4 sales surpass 30 million units

PlayStation 4 sales surpass 30 million units

Gryllis 4 days News 0 8
Songs added to Just Dance Unlimited subscription service
Gryllis 4 days News 0 2

Community Content

#PAXAUS Melbourne Tourist Guide

#PAXAUS Melbourne Tourist Guide

29/10/2015 Blog 10 0

MMGN Updates


commented on Beyond: Two Souls review

Huddo 1 day ago

Gryllis, MyFragian, Tano commented on Channel 9 is now in HD so retune your TV, live streaming app coming in 2016

Gryllis 2 days ago

commented on Sign up for the DOOM closed alpha

Hoover1979 2 days ago

PsFan is now Level 9!

PsFan 2 days ago

Mobe1969, kangle4, Matrix6, capt_oats commented on Watch the Captain America: Civil War trailer everyone is raving about

Mobe1969 3 days ago