Ninja Gaiden 3's 3/10 review – a retort

by Leigh Harris Featured 9 Comments 23 Votes 3579 Views 22/03/2012 Back to Articles

Why do you play Ninja Gaiden? Are you a masochist who enjoys the thrill of being repeatedly pummelled five or ten times at the introduction of a new enemy until you can finally figure out how to dodge their attacks? Or are you a wanton sadist who delights in the carnage and mayhem you can unleash? Perhaps it’s the style of the series, which it oozes in droves?

Whatever the case may be, our dear friend Mitch Dyer over at IGN has made that decision for you in his review. He asserts that the unrelenting challenge is the only reason anyone is a fan of the series, and goes on to rip Ninja Gaiden 3 apart, stating it:

  • "Betrays fans"
  • is “a gash on the face of the franchise and one of the worst games the action genre has yet suffered.”
  • “has no consideration for its fans’ wants or what a new audience may have enjoyed.”

And the grand conclusion to the rant is the unequivocally stark: ,"Under no circumstance should you ever waste your time on this self-indulgent and abysmal wreck."

Three out of ten.

Now, reviews across the board have been fairly unanimous in labelling NG3 the poorest in the series, but it’s been interesting to watch the reactions from undoubtedly hardcore fans uniformly heap scorn on this latest instalment for reasons which totally fly in the face of my (and therefore I must assume it’s safe to assert) and other fans’ enjoyment of it.

At this point I feel I must direct you to a brief, funny manifesto of sorts by a busy guy with not a lot of time on his hands who may have grown up as a hardcore gamer who could dedicate dozens of hours to learning the ropes of each new RTS, but who, over time, had less time to offer, but had absolutely zero inclination to immerse himself in (shudder) casual games.

I sat down to play NG3, selecting hard mode out the gate, as I had done on NG2, getting my ego all stirred-up and preparing for the onslaught. After managing to get my ass kicked in the first level before the first major save point, I rescinded, started a new game on ‘normal’ mode and had a second crack. It’s not that I felt incapable or that the game was unduly harder than previous iterations – it was just that while I’m very excited about the shuriken-throwing, bow-wielding, sword-slashing, blood-curdling and mind-bendingly gory experience a Ninja Gaiden game has to offer, these days I’m happy to just kick back, let the aesthetic glory wash over me and bask in the soothing splatter of a million enemies’ blood. Mmmm… delicious.

So here I am, only a couple of play sessions later and I’ve got my fix: the game is completed, the forgettable story behind me, but my ol’ memory banks are stored up with yet another bunch of the most stand-out moments of shock, awe and action aplenty from a new Ninja Gaiden experience.

Many complaints Dyer raises in his review are quite valid. The story is poor (but no worse than any other NG game to date), the weapon selection is very limited (although it’s not ONE weapon as he suggests), the difficulty has been changed up to appeal to a more mainstream audience, the camera is as usual a bit of an interference (although the lack of precision required to land each blow mitigates that), and the slow-motion sections where Ryu’s arm become hugely painful don’t add anything to the gameplay (Dyer seems to have missed that these points were designed to make the player feel simultaneously helpless and yet able to persevere, which they do exceedingly well).

But these problems, if you’re a player like me who enjoys the fluid motion, the feeling of power, the fretful swordfighting and the reward of some nonsensical over-the-top action cut scenes, and doesn’t particularly like the ‘challenge’ of not having any health after a boss battle and still being forced to trudge an extra few hundred metres to a save point, are moot. I was almost half way through NG3 before I even *noticed* that I hadn’t had a chance to pick up a new weapon yet. Playing a game ‘correctly’, playing to ‘win’, and playing to conquer a challenge have lost their appeal over the years. These days, I like things to be challenging enough, but I don’t want to have to grind, allocate experience points, level up, repair weapons, die repeatedly, be ‘challenged’ by harsh save points or smash every bit of pottery in the nearby area for extra XP.

Bottom line is this: Dyer doesn’t speak for everyone, even if his review asserts its righteousness as though he does. If you’re a Ninja Gaiden fan and you don’t take life too seriously, NG3 is a valid entry into a great series. I agree that it’s the poorest title in the series so far. But I’m still one of those folk who believe a 3/10 game is one which is fundamentally broken, borderline unplayable.

Ignore the haters on this one – it’s still Ninja Gaiden and there’s still plenty to love.

By Leigh Harris - Tweet @leighformayor

Link to us http://PS3.mmgn.com/Articles/Ninja-Gaiden-3s-3-10-review-a-retort
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Ninja Gaiden III

Ninja Gaiden III Ninja Gaiden III Ninja Gaiden III Ninja Gaiden III Ninja Gaiden III Ninja Gaiden III Ninja Gaiden III
Game Profile: Ninja Gaiden III
Ninja Gaiden III Australian Release: Out Now

Ninja Gaiden 3's 3/10 review – a retort Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
I agree, a 3/10 score is a bit too steep in my opinion and should ONLY go to EXTREMELY poor titles.

Ninja Gaiden changed, but somehow I doubt it deserves a 3.
Wow, a 3/10? Did not expect that. Seems a bit harsh to give it that when in all seriousness, there's nothing really wrong with it.
I was reading up on differences between this and the previous 2, what's missing from this is what made the first 2 sooo good
NG3 is not that bad. Sure it's not a 9/10 and it took things from the game fans loved (including myself) but it's a 7.5/8 at best. It's a shame how people who said they enjoyed the game are getting attacked by Itagaki fanboys instead of being respected for their honest opinions. Yes, the game could have been better but it's far from a 3.
the worst one in the series to date why they would want to bring a Ninja to fight Tanks is beyond me, get back to your roots Ninja and we all just might love you again (you sold out) [Facepalm]
Just got the game today, played two hours of it so far and it's pretty alright. I never played any of the past NG games so I didn't have that many expectations but I am let down by the excessive quick time events and loss of gore. I'm not a gore maniac but I love games like these where you can vent out and chopping off limbs just adds in that extra oomph.

A 3/10 should be for games that are straight up unplayable, plagued with bugs and the such. I didn't see this in NG3 at all.
Good article.

I have played all the NG and yes this is not as hard as the others and they have changed some things. On one hand i can see what they have tried to do and i can see see why people hate it but 3/10 cmon its not that bad id prob give it a 7/10. I do miss the hard boss fights but it doesnt bother me that i dont have different weapons to choose from or 4 different nimpos in the other games i tended to stick with one weapon and one certain nimpo anyway.
wow 3 your so bad

gammaray13 said: the worst one in the series to date why they would want to bring a Ninja to fight Tanks is beyond me, get back to your roots Ninja and we all just might love you again (you sold out)



The first had Ryu fight a tank...have you even played it?

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III
  • Ninja Gaiden III

Recently Read

Featured PS3 Content

Games of October: Your most wanted

Games of October: Your most wanted

06/10/2014 Polls 8 16
Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel review

Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel review

Tano 20 hours Reviews 2 3
Win Samurai Warriors 4 on PS4

Win Samurai Warriors 4 on PS4

Tano 21 hours News 3 4
Skylanders Trap Team review

Skylanders Trap Team review

Gryllis 1 day Reviews 2 2
Friendly Fire Show 72: That

Friendly Fire Show 72: That's the joke

Podcast 1 day Articles 0 2
A dance track made from Borderlands sound effects

A dance track made from Borderlands sound effects

Tano 1 day News 1 3
Inside Sledgehammer Games: CoD

Inside Sledgehammer Games: CoD's newest developer

Gryllis 4 days Articles 2 13
Final Fantasy VII's Midgar recreated in Minecraft

Final Fantasy VII's Midgar recreated in Minecraft

Tano 4 days News 7 6
F1 2014 races onto the scene for last-gen only
Gryllis 5 days News 4 6

Community Content

Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

02/09/2014 Blog 10 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

OrangeBlck, Enarium commented on didgio digital giveaway: Win 1 of 50 PC game codes

OrangeBlck 7 hours ago
Username

commented on Ultimate NES Remix coming to 3DS in November

xevious 7 hours ago
Username

commented on Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel review

stonecold 8 hours ago
Username

juggerhead just unlocked the Welcomed achievement!

juggerhead 13 hours ago
Username

commented on Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel review

Olly 14 hours ago
Username

commented on Win Samurai Warriors 4 on PS4

SilentOne 20 hours ago