Dead Space 3 and the double-edged saw blade of accessibility

by James O'Connor Featured 5 Comments 15 Votes 8019 Views 14/02/2013 Back to Articles

Although I’m only five hours into it, I’m really enjoying Dead Space 3. I’ve enjoyed the enemy encounters and the environments, and the weird little set pieces in space. I’ve enjoyed stomping creature-piñatas and having ammo and health fly out of them. I never really enjoyed the first Dead Space, and appreciated the second one but found the idea of actually playing it made me very anxious after the first hour and a half or so. But in Dead Space 3, on Normal difficulty, I’m having a great time.

I’m not entirely convinced that this is a good thing.

The movement in ‘horror’ games towards mainstream accessibility has benefited many. Look at Resident Evil 4 – it took a horror series and made it palatable for those of us who could never quite bear the original games, taking out the ink ribbon system and fixed camera and adding in a combat system that made fighting back both viable and essential. The series would eventually mutate into something extremely messy in Resident Evil 6 (which has missed its sales targets), but Resident Evil 4 remains one of the best action games ever made.

And there’s the thing – RE4 got away with being what it was not because Resident Evil fans were crying out for a new style of gameplay, but because it was phenomenally well designed. And now, eight years after the game’s initial release, fans of the original Resident Evil don’t really have their genre anymore (save for the good-but-not-great Silent Hill: Downpour, which didn’t hold a candle to the older Silent Hill games).

If it signals where the series is headed, I’d argue that the players won over by Dead Space 3 are less likely to be interested in Dead Space 4 and 5.

Dead Space was never really my thing, I suppose, and that’s why I feel bad about enjoying the third game so much. So many developers are already making games that I’m totally into. My shelves are filled with games and genres that I’d hate to see have their core essence diluted. What if Broken Sword 5 launched with puzzles that have been toned down so that anyone could solve easily , I wonder? What if the next Hitman is more like Absolution and less like Blood Money? What if Nintendo never bothers to make another 3D Mario because the 2D ones sell better, and are enjoyed more widely?

I don’t think Dead Space 3 goes quite far enough to alienate Dead Space fans. But if it signals where the series is headed, I’d argue that the players won over by Dead Space 3 are less likely to be interested in Dead Space 4 and 5 than the people who had been with the series from the start would have if the game had continually been designed to appease them. The initial dip in sales on Dead Space 3 could well suggest that I’m onto something here.

Most of all, I worry that if more and more AAA games are designed to garner wider appeal, they’ll all start to look the same. For all the enjoyment I’m getting out of it, DS3 feels a little generic outside of the weapon-building benches, and as much as I don’t mind the lack of scares they made the last two games stand out.

Basically, I’m comfortable with some great games simply not being aimed at me. It’s wonderful that Dark Souls exists, for instance, and has been successful purely by being really good – I can’t bring myself to start playing my copy again, but that’s beside the point, because plenty of other people can. If winning someone like me over means upsetting loyalist fans, I’m happy to go back to whatever I was playing before.

By James O'Connor

Link to us http://PS3.mmgn.com/Articles/dead-space-3-accessibility
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Dead Space 3

Dead Space 3 - First Screenshot Dead Space 3 Dead Space 3 Dead Space 3 Dead Space 3 Dead Space 3 Dead Space 3

Dead Space 3 and the double-edged saw blade of accessibility Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
To be totally honest, I never really got into Dead Space. But I at least enjoyed the original for doing something somewhat unique.

DS2 felt like just another shooter, and DS3 (after 2-3 hours) feels much the same. I'm not really into it.
I am a fan of 1st and 3rd person shooters and my back catalogue is getting scarily large.
Meanwhile gamers into horror, and decent jrps (Nino kuni aside) have bare shelves.
Sellout devs i say.
i didnt play much of Dead space 1 but i like what they did with the game.
then i started playing the 2nd on and was like this is kind of driffting away from the 1st one in gameplay
I sort of know what you are saying yet if dead space 2 & 3 were exactly the same as 1, I am sure there would be articles saying "Hey you have just made the same game but with better graphics!". Also no offence James but playing Dead Space 3 on normal sort of makes it a walk in the park. Playing on harder difficulty is what also helps to build the tension with less ammo & harder enemies
Great article. My thoughts exactly. The game is mindless fun more than anything, and the more complicated parts are purposefully complex to encourage microtransactions as an easy alternative IMO. I recommend you finish the game and try it on the harder difficulty with limited resources and/or permadeath. Makes for a GREAT survival experience.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Dead Space 3 - First Screenshot
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3
  • Dead Space 3Dead Space 3 Video
  • Dead Space 3Dead Space 3 Video
  • Dead Space 3Dead Space 3 Video

Recently Read

Featured PS3 Content

Destiny beta - What do you think?

Destiny beta - What do you think?

4 days ago Polls 1 4
Dark Souls 2: Crown of the Sunken King DLC review

Dark Souls 2: Crown of the Sunken King DLC review

PaulV 46 mins Reviews 0 4
Remember co-op games being fun for being awful?

Remember co-op games being fun for being awful?

Jickle 1 hour Articles 0 2
Win an exclusive spot in the Assassin

Win an exclusive spot in the Assassin's Creed Unity TV ad!

MMGN 2 hours News 10 21
Google is buying Twitch for $1 billion (via YouTube)
Gryllis 6 hours News 2 6
PS4 update adds 3D Blu-ray support next week

PS4 update adds 3D Blu-ray support next week

Gryllis 6 hours News 0 4
Disney Infinity 2.0: Marvel Super Heroes AU date
Gryllis 6 hours News 1 5
Destiny beta now open to everyone (no codes required)

Destiny beta now open to everyone (no codes required)

Gryllis 7 hours News 6 14
Why was Battlefield: Hardline delayed? EA responds

Why was Battlefield: Hardline delayed? EA responds

Tano 1 day News 4 21

Community Content

A New Era For MMGN: Our New HQ

A New Era For MMGN: Our New HQ

23/06/2014 Blog 16 1

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

Tano shared a story - My proudest individual achievement

Tano 1 hour ago
Username

K4ZMA, maxiboy commented on Google is buying Twitch for $1 billion (via YouTube)

K4ZMA 5 hours ago
Username

Daemoroth just unlocked the Welcomed achievement!

Daemoroth 5 hours ago
Username

Tano, Gryllis commented on Hot Tub Time Machine 2 - Red Band Trailer

Tano 5 hours ago
Username

1wiierdguy is now Level 19!

1wiierdguy 7 hours ago
Username

commented on Why was Battlefield: Hardline delayed? EA responds

Shadow99 8 hours ago
Username

1wiierdguy is now Level 19!

1wiierdguy 22 hours ago
Username

chris991 is selling - GTA V PS3

chris991 1 day ago