AFL Talk 10 - Locked

Demoted 96750 Views 2828 Posts Locked Social
Continue on from here: ps3.mmgn.com/...


MMGN Supercoach league number is:568834

MMGN DreamTeam league number is:508182

This might help for choosing a team:

Round 11 byes: Adelaide, Brisbane Lions, Greater Western Sydney, North Melbourne, West Coast, Western Bulldogs
Round 12 byes: Collingwood, Essendon, Fremantle, Geelong, Melbourne, Sydney Swans
Round 13 byes: Carlton, Gold Coast, Hawthorn, Port Adelaide, Richmond, St Kilda

Go Swans!

Seanybruz said:

Dusty Lids said: ewww... greene my new rookie out this week with soreness fml
and redden rested. James mcdonald could be the sub. same as ellis.
pehediffer > milera and dickson>greene better not come back to bite
Saints are assholes not bringing in ledger as well.


Yeah I shouldn't have traded Milera into the side ahead of Dazza I knew he'd get an opportunity, on the plus side glad I didn't trade out Thomas Couch who hopefully gets a crack for Melbourne another mature ager let's hope he's another Magner.
Still not sure if I'll make a trade might just do Fyfe to Goddard weighing up that trade.

gammaray13 said: port to smash the pies lol how funny will that be, and it will happen


Ease up a little haha, they still have a ton of class in that side Swan, Pendles, Cloke, Jolly etc I just don't want us to get smashed, I must say I regret not jumping on the $8 odds earlier in the week though.
Glad to see Butcher in if we can win some of the midfield battle we should be able to kick a decent score.


buddy you will win by at least 6 goals, the so called class players you say they have are like 12 year old school boys with no direction, if you cant beat them this week you never will there in more trouble than naked chick in room full of drunk footballers
Interesting analogy...
Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Massively regretting trading out Lachie Neale for Clay Smith in SC, always happens to two of my rookies each season when I make knee jerk selections based on one good game.
Wouldn't call Jolly 'class'. He's in horrible form. Probably in the twilight of his career.

Though the Colliwobbles will still win, you'd think. If it was in Adelaide... maybe Port.

iSR said: Wouldn't call Jolly 'class'. He's in horrible form. Probably in the twilight of his career.
Though the Colliwobbles will still win, you'd think. If it was in Adelaide... maybe Port.



Agreed Jolly looks to have lost all that form that made him so good I feel the Swans let go of him at a good time despite us not wanting to lose him, he hasn't really dominated a game for quite a while.

Mumford over Jolly, Swans win out :D
Ok replace Jolly with Sidebottom in the class bracket, Beames has also performed well against us in the past.

Was funny seeing Barry Hall tip us on 360 on the basis of 3-4 tall forwards against Lachlan Keefe as their only tall backs, still have to get the ball forward Bazza =_=
Mmm.. clearly didn't see Kreuzer jumping over the top of Jolly at every single contest last week. Absolutely dominated him. I'd even go as far to say Collingwood has one of the bottom 5 ruck options in the league now.

winga26 said:

iSR said: Wouldn't call Jolly 'class'. He's in horrible form. Probably in the twilight of his career.
Though the Colliwobbles will still win, you'd think. If it was in Adelaide... maybe Port.


Agreed Jolly looks to have lost all that form that made him so good I feel the Swans let go of him at a good time despite us not wanting to lose him, he hasn't really dominated a game for quite a while.
Mumford over Jolly, Swans win out



The only reason Jolly left the Swans was because his wife wanted to move back to Melbourne. I was pissed at the time but it has worked out well.
Still a win :P
Are people tipping Saints or Freo tonight?

I don't know who to tip [Shifty]
Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
freo for me and dees over dogs :P
I tipped Freo, but it's a hard one.

If it was in Perf I'd be a lot more confident.

IAMColonel said:I'd even go as far to say Collingwood has one of the bottom 5 ruck options in the league now.



Just because I like putting things in lists... :P

(best to worst)

Cox/Naitanui
Sandilands/Clarke
Kruezer/Hampson/Warnock
Mumford/Seaby
Ryder/Hille/Bellchambers
Goldstein/McIntosh
Leuenberger/Hudson/Longer
Jamar/Martin/Clarke
Hale/Roughead/Bailey/McCauley
West/Stephenson
McIvoy
Jacobs
Jolly/Wood
Maric/Graham
Smith/Fraser
Giles/Brogan
Roughead/Cordy/Minson
Redden/Renouf

Post yours if you think I am wrong ;)
Lobbe is probably Port's best ruckman. Was better than Brogan last year, but only when he had real support (i.e. not Westhoff).

Injured [Facepalm]
But he's been injured for like a decade straight :P Drafted in 07, played like 12 games? Poor kid.

It's really harsh having Port on bottom, sorry. I think Renouf will probably make an impact this week, not sure why he isn't in their best 22 though?
Richmond's would be Maric/Vickery... Graham hasn't played yet. And I'd say Richmond's could be lower. Smith and Fraser are definitely a better combo and by years end Giles and Brogan could be better too.

IAMColonel said: But he's been injured for like a decade straight Drafted in 07, played like 12 games? Poor kid.
It's really harsh having Port on bottom, sorry. I think Renouf will probably make an impact this week, not sure why he isn't in their best 22 though?



He's in this week.

Got injured in the preseason and had to get match fitness in the SANFL.

I was kind of hoping they would play Redden and Renouf, since I think Redden would go much better with support, but they have too many tall forwards as it is. Would probably need to drop Westhoff and Stewart for that to happen. Actually, I think Redden was close to Port's best player last week. Held his own against Mumford for 3/4 quarters, but then tired due to rucking mostly on his own, which is too much for a 3 gamer.

Port's ruck is probably their biggest problem though, so bottom is deserved. There's promise, but no real proven players there.
Actually Smith/Fraser should be much higher, GCS are one of the best clearance teams in the comp.

They'd be up their with Goldstein/McIntosh.

Milky said: Richmond's would be Maric/Vickery... Graham hasn't played yet. And I'd say Richmond's could be lower. Smith and Fraser are definitely a better combo and by years end Giles and Brogan could be better too.



Yeah true. They all seem to chuck their tall forward options in as a second ruck now. Should really put Koshitze and Tippett in there as well.I was putting in ruck options though, so a lot of the players haven't played yet, they're just options.

@Ben, Stewart has been good for them as a second ruck. As you said though, it's the fact that you can't really be certain what your best combination is, because none of the players have really proven themselves. Hawks are the same, but then you two great tall forwards in Roughie and Hale to choose to play in ruck, so that makes up for it.

Milky said: Actually Smith/Fraser should be much higher, GCS are one of the best clearance teams in the comp.
They'd be up their with Goldstein/McIntosh.



I just don't like Fraser :P
Can't believe I put 'their' in place of 'there' [Rage]

Friday night footy, who is going to win tonight? Should be an interesting clash. I've tipped Saints, but Freo are capable of causing an upset.
trade fyfe or not? hardest decision ever
Only problem I have with Fyfe is that his break even is about 191 so he's going to go down in price, doesn't matter as much with premiums though so here's hoping he lasts the season.

kangle4 said: Only problem I have with Fyfe is that his break even is about 191 so he's going to go down in price, doesn't matter as much with premiums though so here's hoping he lasts the season.



Yeah but its unlikely. this is the only good chance you get to trade him out or keep him and loss lots of points and money if he gets subbed/rested/injured during the year.

Whitecross looks tempting if he can keep it up will let me pocket 120k:)
Yeah I traded Fyfe for Whitecross.

Milky said: Yeah I traded Fyfe for Whitecross.



Looks great should average 100 for the year i reckon. The monies from this will be amazing:) getting penders early for this will make it a worthy trade
 
Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Featured PS3 Content

GT 6 - Would you rather PS3 or PS4?

GT 6 - Would you rather PS3 or PS4?

13/05/2013 Polls 27 34
Borderlands 2: Let's talk about Krieg the Psycho

Borderlands 2: Let's talk about Krieg the Psycho

PaulV 25 mins Articles 1 4
The Last of Us is about Choice and Death
Tyrus 1 hour News 1 8
Splinter Cell: Blacklist trailer shows off stealthy co-op

Splinter Cell: Blacklist trailer shows off stealthy co-op

Tyrus 1 hour News 0 6
LittleBigPlanet is getting the Mass Effect treatment

LittleBigPlanet is getting the Mass Effect treatment

Tyrus 1 hour News 0 9
PS4 mockup: Is this Sony's new console?

PS4 mockup: Is this Sony's new console?

Tano 2 hours News 5 7
What D-grade Aussie celebs think of COD: Ghosts

What D-grade Aussie celebs think of COD: Ghosts

Gryllis 4 hours News 22 13
Batman: Arkham Origins trailer tackles the inception
Gryllis 4 hours News 0 10
Unpopular gaming opinions

Unpopular gaming opinions

Tano 1 day Articles 33 34

Community Content

New trailer and 35 minutes of Beyond: Two Souls

New trailer and 35 minutes of Beyond: Two Souls

punk 29/04 News 0 10
Ratchet & Clank movie announced!

Ratchet & Clank movie announced!

Blob 23/04 News 9 26
Merchandise - Stuff for consumers you can actually purchase this time!

Merchandise - Stuff for consumers you can actually purchase this time!

1 day ago Blog 0 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

commented on Borderlands 2: Let's talk about Krieg the Psycho

Leasha 7 mins ago
Username

Tano, MoeMan commented on Extra trains to help you get to PAX Australia

Tano 8 mins ago
Username

gammaray13, Tano, Mr. T commented on I see a Remake Opportunity!

gammaray13 23 mins ago
Username

commented on The Last of Us is about Choice and Death

gammaray13 24 mins ago
Username

Tano, Mr. T commented on MURMMUMMGGN DAWT COM

Tano 28 mins ago
Username

gammaray13, Kenni commented on Unpopular gaming opinions people probably hate me for

gammaray13 41 mins ago
Username

kangle4, mandachic commented on Jack Reacher DVD Giveaway

kangle4 44 mins ago
Username

kangle4, Josh commented on Tomorrow's Xbox reveal is part 1 of 2

kangle4 45 mins ago
Username

GreenThumb, Lekkers, Tano, nDR01d commented on What do D-grade Aussie "celebs" think of Call of Duty: Ghosts?

GreenThumb 1 hour ago
Username

commented on 8Bit Goes Green

Mr. T 2 hours ago