AFL Talk 10 - Locked

Demoted 98921 Views 2828 Posts Locked Social

Kudos: 74,272

Continue on from here: ps3.mmgn.com/...

MMGN Supercoach league number is:568834

MMGN DreamTeam league number is:508182

This might help for choosing a team:

Round 11 byes: Adelaide, Brisbane Lions, Greater Western Sydney, North Melbourne, West Coast, Western Bulldogs
Round 12 byes: Collingwood, Essendon, Fremantle, Geelong, Melbourne, Sydney Swans
Round 13 byes: Carlton, Gold Coast, Hawthorn, Port Adelaide, Richmond, St Kilda

Go Swans!

01/02/2012

GET YOUR BLOOD PUMPING - GO SWANS!

Kudos: 23,072

Seanybruz

iSR said:
Was funny last night listening to talkback while going to bed. As I was drifting off I swear I heard a Melbourne supporter say, "That Sellar has talent" while going through who their better players are.

Sellar may do a Jon Giles ie delisted fairly for not showing much by past coach, then gets picked up & given opportunity at another club by said coach that sacked him & turns it around.

I was just surprised that he got picked ahead of Couch who I reckon could add abit to their team like Magner has, really need him playing by the time the byes hit don't wanna waste a trade when he can play good footy.

Just when he was at the Crows Sellar was terrible, when he was drafted the headline was 'Travis Boak controversially picked ahead of James Sellar' :P

28/05/2012

Adelaide

Kudos: 12,852

iSR

Would be good if Couch got a game, just for the fact that he's so cheap... you could get alot of cash downgrading to him. Doesn't even matter about his scoring (50-60 on bench would do).

28/05/2012

Perth, WA |

Leave a comment

Kudos: 44,046

Dusty Lids

screw beams i am going with robinson. like 70k cheaper then i can get an ultra premium the week after with the cash i have left. Both do the same thing only i see more positives with robbo. Once swan comes back i can see it effecting his output. Robbo will be a lot better with no murphy for most of the season.

Please Couch or mitchell get announced so i can do this trade :D

Keeping whitecross. Can afford to now:P

Only problem will be is treloar sitting on the bench.

28/05/2012

Melbourne

Kudos: 44,046

Dusty Lids

considering going for scotland/waters.

since their is no need to upgrade to beams, sidebottom, robinson.

Far too expensive the first 2 and i would rather get rid of morris who is spudding it up every frigging week.

Robinson and beams i consider risky and with treloar as my foward 7 i reckon its a better idea to upgrade where its really needed.

Out milera in couch, if he plays:P

out morris in scotland/waters. Leaning towards scotland based on getting priddis next week.

29/05/2012

Melbourne

Kudos: 12,852

iSR

Robinson and Beams risky? I'll enjoy them then! :P

Treloar won't score 100+ every week... so that's probably more risky.

29/05/2012

Perth, WA |

Kudos: 44,046

Dusty Lids

its not like robinson and beams will out perform premium mids for much longer. As long as they do not rise over 600k i will be ok.

robinson is inconsistant.

29/05/2012

Melbourne

Kudos: 74,272

winga26

I don't think I'd go with Robinson either I just havnt see him enough this year to have him as a premium.

29/05/2012

GET YOUR BLOOD PUMPING - GO SWANS!

Kudos: 44,046

Dusty Lids

we all know scotland will average 100 no problem. gets me an extra 40+ points each week. Best to go for reliability.

robbo yeh could be great but treloar is also good enough as my f7 for a few weeks yet. Averaging 90+ last few weeks. Will be perfect to upgrade him to best available in a few weeks.

No more risks imo. been screwed by majority of those:P

its pointless to upgrade as it would only be worth it if robbo can average 130+ every week. doubt it

29/05/2012

Melbourne

Kudos: 2,684

jroons

im not sure if this has been mentioned but Dangerfield has signed a 3 yr contract extension with the Crows. :D

30/05/2012

Adelaide

Kudos: 12,852

iSR

Dusty Lids said: its not like robinson and beams will out perform premium mids for much longer. As long as they do not rise over 600k i will be ok.
robinson is inconsistant.

Oh, I always forget you're talking about SC. Has been super-consistent in DT.

30/05/2012

Perth, WA |

Leave a comment

Kudos: 552

45vdub

Beta said: Can we create a different discussion for DT/SC?
@Milky - Didn't I tell you Richmond would push? Hawthorn is shit.

beta maybe u and i can go over to the DT/SC thread and talk actual football if no-one actually uses it -_-

30/05/2012

Kudos: 74,272

winga26

We've got the two threads but neither are that busy it's a problem is it?

Anyways Friday night is set to be a cracker with the Tigers vs Saints, the Tigers are one of the best sides to watch imo.

30/05/2012

GET YOUR BLOOD PUMPING - GO SWANS!

Kudos: 28,868

stonecold

winga26 said: We've got the two threads but neither are that busy it's a problem is it?
Anyways Friday night is set to be a cracker with the Tigers vs Saints, the Tigers are one of the best sides to watch imo.

I think saints will win, only cause its at Etihad, but should be a close contest.
North will get smashed :P :D

30/05/2012

Kudos: 51,826

Milky

winga26 said: We've got the two threads but neither are that busy it's a problem is it?

Yeah agreed, I don't see an issue with having 1 thread for all AFL talk. It isn't like we are chewing through 20 pages a day and most posts contain both regular chat and DT/SC chat.

30/05/2012

come on, i only want a cuddle!

Kudos: 31,145

IAMColonel

Most the time the SC is just to fill in the off days. If something interesting happens then we talk about it. Do you really want to discuss Gary Ablett grabbing Thompson's shirt for the fourth day running, like the media has been today? By all means go ahead and bring something up, we will stop the SC talk.

30/05/2012

Melbourne

Kudos: 23,072

Seanybruz

On the odd occasion I actually post in the other thread no one even visits it or responds like my recent unanswered question lol.

I don't see it as a big deal this thread is normally dead if you take out the fantasy comp talk, like IAC said no one is stopping anybody from talking about normal footy news.

30/05/2012

Adelaide

Kudos: 51,826

Milky

30/05/2012

come on, i only want a cuddle!

Kudos: 12,852

iSR

Also.. why does everyone play SC and not DT? Or at least focus on the former?

30/05/2012

Perth, WA |

Kudos: 51,826

Milky

iSR said: Also.. why does everyone play SC and not DT? Or at least focus on the former?

I play DT and not SC. SC is very eastern states, don't know anybody over here in Perth that uses it.

30/05/2012

come on, i only want a cuddle!

Kudos: 40,310

WiiSUME1up

31/05/2012

Jersey Shore

Kudos: 12,371

kangle4

Milky said:
iSR said: Also.. why does everyone play SC and not DT? Or at least focus on the former?
I play DT and not SC. SC is very eastern states, don't know anybody over here in Perth that uses it.

Supercoach is run through the Herald Sun website so that's why you probably don't get it as much over there. It may just be over here but because it's in the Sun it gets a lot more attention and has more players.

31/05/2012

Melbourne, Victoria

Kudos: 12,852

iSR

I'm pretty sure PerthNow (online equivalent of HS) runs SC as well. Though it's separate from the West Australian Newspaper, so I can see why SC might get more attention through the physical HS as well.

31/05/2012

Perth, WA |

Kudos: 12,371

kangle4

Heath Shaw out :'@

Mummy back :)

31/05/2012

Melbourne, Victoria

Kudos: 74,272

winga26

kangle4 said: Heath Shaw out
Mummy back

I'm surprised LRT and AJ are named despite struggling with a heel injury and an elbow injury. :O

Do you think Mummy will defiantly play? I hope he does and plays half in ruck and half in the forward line, we can't afford to over use him in the ruck any more.

31/05/2012

GET YOUR BLOOD PUMPING - GO SWANS!

Kudos: 44,046

Dusty Lids

No Couch/ Mitchell. Not impressed:P needed a rookie to downgrade too.

Guess i can risk with couch. But even though he is getting 40 touches a game he is not good enough for melbourne.

31/05/2012

Melbourne