"Nothing more damaging" than violent games - NSW Police Commissioner

by Ben Salter Featured 47 Comments 36 Votes 2122 Views 06/08/2012 Back to News

New South Wales Police Commissioner Andrew Scipione has lashed out at violent video games and movies this morning, stating that nothing is potentially more damaging for children.

There is "nothing more potentially damaging than the sort of violence they're [children] being exposed to, be it in movies, be it in console games they're playing," Scipione told The Daily Telegraph.

"How can it not affect you if you're a young adolescent growing up in an era where to be violent is almost praiseworthy, where you engage in virtual crime on a daily basis and many of these young people (do) for hours and hours on end," he said.

"You get rewarded for killing people, raping women, stealing money from prostitutes, driving cars crashing and killing people."

His comments are refuted by numerous studies on the issue; however, they come after a spate of violent crimes involving adolescents around the country during the last month.

Dr Chistopher Ferguson later responded, telling The Daily Telegraph that Mr Scipione's claims were "irresponsible" and "based on no good research data as an emotional reaction to a 'recent spate' of knifings that could simply be due to a random fluctuation in crime rates".

By Ben Salter

Link to us http://PS3.mmgn.com/News/nothing-more-damaging-than-violent-game
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

"Nothing more damaging" than violent games - NSW Police Commissioner Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Why am I not a murderer then? I played heaps of violent games when I was younger
lol, watching the news is far more "damaging"...and worse of all, it is completely REAL! Therefore, the thought of imitating it is more conceivable.
I've played many violent games before. Never hit someone or done something illegal before.

The news is real and gives people ideas. Reading about the Colorado shooting and someone else got arrested for planning something like that because he heard it on the news.
that guy is an idiot, the cops worry about normal people doing 5ks over the speed limit and not doing anything about the real crims, plus criminals are too stupid to play games
Doesn't make sense either. My bro is a police officer and he's been playing violent games since he was 8

M@ndyz said: Doesn't make sense either. My bro is a police officer and he's been playing violent games since he was 8


lol thats so funny i also have a mate who is a cop and he loves games
They're covering this topic on the '7PM Project' tonight.
Violent games, more damaging than drugs.

...be it in console games they're playing...



So....if I play any of those games on PC, I'm all good?

But seriously, kids shouldn't be playing games that reward you "...for killing people, raping women, stealing money from prostitutes, driving cars crashing and killing people" until they're old enough and mature enough to realize that's it's just over the top mature entertainment that's meant to be taken lightly. That's what the rating system is there for. And even then, if you've got a 17 year old who still goes around hitting dogs and babies with sticks, their parent should have the common sense to say "Okay, you're obviously not mature enough to withstand the influence these games can have on you" and keep them from playing them.

Don't blame the games for influencing a child when their parents are the ones that have let them play them when they're obviously not mature enough.

virtual

Yeah, we might take your claims a bit more seriously Mr Scipione, when you show us your qualifications and research into child and adolescent psychology...

FFS [Facepalm]
Nothing more damaging than the Government giving citizens false information.
It's not games, it's a lack of discipline.

Milky said: Nothing more damaging than the Government.



Efa

Anyway, this is a clear result of ignorance and ultra conservatism. Games are a scapegoat for poor parenting.
Your heads more damaging to my eyes than any game could be.

[MOG]
The sad thing is people will eat this crap up for breakfast. :/

Has anyone seen the statistics which show that Aussie crime rates have gone down since the mainstream integration of video games within society?

It is my opinion that those who seek to kill, or hurt people or whatever can do that in a video game and be satisfied. Those who can't tell the difference between real life and video games, I'd argue, are mentally ill anyway and were going to be pushed over the edge anyway..

Sad that this argument still continues. Maybe the issue is bad parenting, disorganised government bodies (eg. corrupt police, a failing justice system, just to name a few) etc.

When will people stand up and take responsibility?

tl;dr? People need to stop playing the blame game.
There is a leaking tap

You can identify the problem and resolve it. Or you can blame possoms and petition the government to have them exterminated. It wont fix the tap but at least you get to make a noise.

When scapegoats are created, the only people who win are the perpetrators. Thanks for rationalising their crimes. I guess they are the real victims. [Facepalm]
Time for someone to pull their head out their ass, the issue has nothing to do with games/movies most of the people commiting these crimes are brought up to be ferals by ferals. It's a part of life sadly we will always have this disrespectful part of society.

I can use myself as an example to say that I've played violent games and I've turned out fine, I'm not violent have never committed a crime and I show respect to everyone.
Can't believe I tuned into the project when it was virtually the same bullcrap they said last time they talked about the 'issue'.

They even had Pricey the angry midget on again to tell us all about how he used to play pacman [Facepalm]

$10 says this cop has a son who is a gamer, he is just trying to make this an issue without any substance at all to back his claims up...
nothing more damaging then games? I beg to differ.

Child ... meet chainsaw.
Tano
+

GreenThumb said: Your heads more damaging to my eyes than any game could be.



HEY-O!

Thats why they aren't rated for children. That guy can go blow it out his backside
This 'blame it on the video games' thing is way too old. Seriously how many times have we heard this in the media now?? I honestly thought society had pretty much moved forward from this issue, guess I overestimated some people.
Do they pull these puppets out of a led-lined shipping container?
the interwebs have more damaging things than video games but people seem to over look that :S

Desi
+
Notice that he mentioned console games being damaging and harmful, and not PC games. ;)

/troll

Desi said: Notice that he mentioned console games being damaging and harmful, and not PC games.
/troll



That's because gaming is all about consoles not PC.

/troll back :P
I shoudl probs go tell my friends that im going to shoot them .....
These kids that commit the crimes most likely aren't gamers or the only game they actually play is Call of Duty :P
i've been playing video games since i was 4 and im 20 and i've never hit someone or done something illegal before.


Violence in video games is nothing when you compare other external influences impacting on a persons health. A child isn't raised by a video game, in the end it is a parents decision on what they expose their children to (domestic violence and alcoholism anyone?). To blame violence in video games is somewhat naive, considering there are drugs and weapons that are designed for causing damage. The link between mental illness seems to me at least to be a more prevalent issue.

Columbine raised this issue of violent video games a number of years ago, and there was even a lawsuit filed against the games industry (which failed). The truth is, no one is raised to become a murderous machine, just as games weren't created to breed killers. Gaming is a form of entertainment, and stress relief from the burdens of everyday life. I don't mean to offend our beloved police commissioner, but video games take that physical 'violence' off of our streets, and contains it to virtual reality of the video game universe.
Notice how he says IN MOVIES TOO!?!??! :E
I came across this recently, somehow I feel it's relevant [Shifty]

www.landoverbaptist.net/...
So if i play violent games, That means i'm going to be a violent person...

If i play say... Fifa... Am i going to be a pro player? [MOG]

GreenThumb said: So if i play violent games, That means i'm going to be a violent person...
If i play say... Fifa... Am i going to be a pro player?



I am one of the best players on afl 2011 live why the **** am i not drafted? i know i am 25 but with someone of my talent surely deserve a shot:P

Best to ignore this guy.

Sounds like this cop is sick and twisted. What game has parts where you can rape people??? go do your job you pig and stop these criminal actions in the real world.

Police commissioners are always smart and correct.



Said no one ever.
Excuse me Mr. Commissioner, but what game do you get rewarded for raping women? Obviously you have played that game, and something tells me that such a game would be illegal in this country.

So if you're such an expert on the issue, and you've been playing that game, then you probably should not be our police commissioner.

Just saying.
He comments that players are rewarded for violence and killing. Yes just like a medal being given to a trained killer or a corrupt police officer stealing money. We are giving youth plenty to get angry about here in the real world.
I heard playing video games gives you cancer >_>

what an absolute flop. He lives in Australia and should know you can't rape in video games.

I find playing video games calming if not remedial. If I've had a stressful day and play a game I'll be completely cleansed. Been playing since I was a kid.

Movies had more of an influence on me not that I watched anything violent. Was way too scared to even watch gremlins. First time I watched predator. Had nightmares for weeks .
CONVINCES ME NOT TO PLAY VIDEO GAMES! ):<
NEVER PLAYING A GAME AGAIN.

loljks.
I've never played a game that involves rape.
People have been raping each other for millions of years.
Why?
VIDEO GAMES OF COURSE.

Which ones?

Call of Duty.
Of course, if his claim was correct, all the middle class neighbourhoods where game consoles are most common would be going to hell with deranged, murderous, raping kids, right?

Heller said: Excuse me Mr. Commissioner, but what game do you get rewarded for raping women? Obviously you have played that game, and something tells me that such a game would be illegal in this country.
So if you're such an expert on the issue, and you've been playing that game, then you probably should not be our police commissioner.
Just saying.



I bet Mikey knows what game :P [Shifty] [MOG]

Makra said: I came across this recently, somehow I feel it's relevant
www.landoverbaptist.net/...



I'm a Roman Catholic and that's one of the funniest things I've read in my entire life.
It's those kinds of Christians that make me feel ashamed to be seen in the same group as them. [Facepalm]
TL;DR, officer is a moron.

Dénor said:

Makra said: I came across this recently, somehow I feel it's relevant
www.landoverbaptist.net/...


I'm a Roman Catholic and that's one of the funniest things I've read in my entire life.
It's those kinds of Christians that make me feel ashamed to be seen in the same group as them.


Hehehe. It's a satire site :P A verrry well done one though. I believed it for a while, it was only checking wikipedia that made me positive it wasn't for real lol.
'Cause you know, I frequently run around stealing cars and killing people... Thanks to video games.

Everyone's entitled to their opinion - including Andrew Scipione - but I'm sorry Andrew, you're wrong and the statistics simply do NOT back-up your claim that video games influence violent behavior...

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured PS3 Content

Xbox One - What do you think?

Xbox One - What do you think?

4 days ago Polls 29 61
Black Flag Wallpapers

Black Flag Wallpapers

Mr. T 1 day Articles 5 7
Good grief, more unpopular gaming opinions

Good grief, more unpopular gaming opinions

Jickle 1 day Articles 16 27
Resident Evil: Revelations HD review

Resident Evil: Revelations HD review

Gryllis 1 day Reviews 5 11
GTA V Australian Collector's Edition revealed

GTA V Australian Collector's Edition revealed

Gryllis 1 day News 28 23
Friendly Fire Cast 20 One: All about the Xbox One
Gryllis 1 day Articles 1 9
Console wars heat up with Need for Speed: Rivals

Console wars heat up with Need for Speed: Rivals

Gryllis 1 day News 6 16
BioWare confirmed for PAX Australia

BioWare confirmed for PAX Australia

Gryllis 2 days News 3 22
Metro: Last Light review

Metro: Last Light review

Tano 2 days Reviews 7 17

Community Content

Black Flag Wallpapers

Black Flag Wallpapers

Mr. T 1 day Articles 5 7
New trailer and 35 minutes of Beyond: Two Souls

New trailer and 35 minutes of Beyond: Two Souls

punk 29/04 News 0 10
Merchandise - Stuff for consumers you can actually purchase this time!

Merchandise - Stuff for consumers you can actually purchase this time!

6 days ago Blog 0 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

commented on Resident Evil: Revelations Giveaway

Natalie351 22 mins ago
Username

commented on Nisekoi anime adaptation confirmed

Blak 3 hours ago
Username

commented on Gameboy Cake

MegaManSec 5 hours ago
Username

gdmatt, Tsunamo, Makra and other 2 users commented on Always watching Kinect could make you pay more if too many people are in the room

gdmatt 6 hours ago
Username

OllyEbbz , Atar commented on Resident Evil: Revelations HD review

OllyEbbz 6 hours ago
Username

Melissalee, EKP, psych and other 6 users commented on Resident Evil: Revelations Giveaway

Melissalee 7 hours ago
Username

commented on Jack Reacher DVD Giveaway

Melissalee 7 hours ago
Username

commented on Turtle Beach pledges support to Xbox One

Marge 8 hours ago
Username

commented on Snitch Double Pass Giveaway

Techa 9 hours ago