Demon’s Souls Review

by Ben Salter Featured

36 Comments 26 Votes 4538 Views 14/07/2010 Back to Reviews

Demon’s Soul Review

Demon’s Souls will eat you alive.

By Ben Salter

Demon’s Souls was all the rage well over a year ago, having been released in Japan and North America in 2009. It’s finally made its way over to Australia and Europe, albeit several months after fans would have imported. There was a time when we thought Demon’s Souls was never going to make it to our shores but thankfully it has. While it mightn’t be everyone’s favourite style of game, it’s a title every PS3 owner should at least experience if, for nothing else, its intense challenge.

Saying Demon’s Souls is a hard game would be an understatement. It’s almost a punishment for those of us who’ve started complaining that games have become too easy and noob-friendly. It takes your gaming ego, punches it in the face and and laughs as you slowly try to pick yourself up, only to fall again. It’s hard to remember games before you could pause. I found that wasn’t an option in Demon’s Souls the hard way, by being burnt to death while trying to navigate my inventory. You’re going to die countless times, for which there is genuine punishment rather than unlimited retries, and it’s going to happen for small things like moving slightly too fast or taking one step too many. It sounds frustrating, and it is, but Demon’s Souls is strangely addictive. For serious RPG fans, Demon’s Souls is like child birth; you know it’s going to be a painful experience, but once you’ve committed and put in the hard yards, it becomes extremely rewarding. If, like me, you’re not a massive RPG fan it’s well worth a rent just to experience the extreme difficulty, but I don’t recommend trying to complete the journey.

Demon’s Souls ReviewHow do I get into these situations?

I don’t want to beat the underlying theme of difficulty to death throughout this review, but it’s hard not to when the game throws up a minor tutorial with a boss most players won’t beat. From the beginning we’re taught that failure is an integral part of Demon’s Souls, a game in which patience is the key. It’s hard to convey just how difficult the game is on paper (or screen), but imagine you’ve just started a new level in Demon’s Souls and are trying to run through as you would in a hack ‘n slash adventure. Now look at your watch ... and ... now ... you’re dead.

Your first problem was trying to play an action-RPG as a hack ‘n slasher. Although they appear similar, they are very different genres. Using a range of attacks, items, magic and most importantly tactics is imperative to success. Trying to massacre everything with your sword will lead to certain death. Picking off enemies one-by-one, or at least avoiding a swam, will greatly increase your chances and only lead to possible death.

After the first few hours it becomes apparent that there’s so much more to combat than you first realised. It’s easy to get stuck in the motions of whatever class you picked and never stray from a repetitive game plan. Purchasing new weapons and mixing it up to expand your horizons will make Demon’s Souls a more compelling experience and might just save your life. If you’re not normally good with a sword and shield it’s best to avoid them here, as missing the parry and perfect striking moment will result in death. A bow or long range magic are great alternatives if you have the patience for them, as are the hundreds of other possible combat combinations. The possibilities are endless and allow unprecedented character development that’s sure to get RPG fans excited, very excited.

Demon’s Souls ReviewYeah man don't get up, I'm just dead again.

How fast you can develop your character is heavily reliant on how often you can stay alive. When you die you’ll become a spirit with half a health bar. The only way to get your physical body back is to defeat a boss, which is hard enough with full health let alone being limited to half. If, or should I way when, you die again all of the souls you’ve collected throughout the level, from kills, will be lost. As a spirit, you must fight your way back to your own bloodstain to regain them and try to fight your way past whatever killed you last time. If you die in the level for a third time, the souls you collected will be gone forever. Considering how hard you have to work to collect souls and that they’re used as currency to upgrade your character, it’s more heartbreaking than being dumped in front of the whole school on the night of your senior formal (I imagine). To make it even more challenging, none of this is really explained all that well, leaving you dead, broke and confused.

After going up against the odds and so much failure, eventually it has to go your way, and that’s what Demon’s Souls is all about: taking on the impossible and winning. Fighting back to the place where you’ve already died four times takes determination, but the accomplishment of getting through and defeating a big-ass monster is one of the most rewarding you’ll experience in any game.

At its core, Demon’s Souls is a single player game and yet you’re not playing it right unless you experience the multiplayer. Jumping online allows you and other players to work together in the punishing dark fantasy world. Other players join your game as blue phantoms and fight by your side to counter the extreme difficulty. Having said that, playing online instigates black phantoms - other players out to kill you and steal your souls. You can’t interact with people at the beginning, reprieving newbies from yet another thing that can kill them, but the black phantom becomes an integral and irritating part of the game later on. After all, unless you know the people you’re gaming with (whether it be in the real or gaming world) it’s much more fun to work against rather than with them.

Demon’s Souls ReviewFire beats everything.

The massive world is dark and gloomy, as it is intended to be and for the most part looks decent. However, you spend way too much time wandering through the shadows waiting to be pounced on by an array of enemies. Often only the immediate area of your character is illuminated, leaving you walking blind. It’s all too easy to walk off a cliff which is by far the most shattering way to die. It’s meant to be a dark medieval-style world, but developer From Software has taken that a little too far and given the game one of its biggest annoyances, infuriating difficulty aside.

Demon’s Souls has a distinctive art style, when you can see it, but suffers from frame-rate issues every now and then. They’re usually brief, but slowdown can be catastrophic in a game that punishes you so severely for making minor mistakes. Some rough edges aside, the giant castles and terrifying monsters have been ripped out of a medieval tale and fit the scene perfectly. The same can be said about the sound effects which add to the dark and gloomy artistic style. Unfortunately the voice acting is utter rubbish and feels terribly out of place, but you can’t win ‘em all.

The Final Verdict

Demon’s Souls is a game every PS3 owner should try, but not one that all will like. If you’re not normally into RPGs Demon’s Souls won’t convert you, quite the contrary. However, if a finely crafted role-playing experience that’ll seriously challenge you sparks your interest, Demon’s Souls is almost the perfect game for you. It’s a hard game, it’s a frustrating game, but if you put in the hard yards it’s a rewarding game.

Gameplay

8.7
Demon’s Souls offers a great RPG, but be warned: it’s extremely frustrating.

Graphics

7.5
Most of the game looks good but never fantastic and there are some frame rate issues.

Sound

8.0
The sound effects are fantastic and fit the dark fantasy world perfectly. Too bad the voice acting is horrendous.

Value

9.5
Demon’s Souls will last you a long time and the people who actually make it to the end will feel compelled to do it all again and help out others online.

Overall

8.7
Demon’s Souls is infuriatingly hard, yet social-life-destroyingly addictive.

Demon's Souls

Platform: PS3
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Demon's Souls

Demon's Souls Demon's Souls Demon's Souls Demon's Souls Demon's Souls Demon's Souls Demon's Souls
Game Profile: Demon's Souls
Demon's Souls Australian Release: Out Now

Demon’s Souls Review Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Nice review. Best game on PS3.
Love the overall score description

"social-life-destroyingly addictive."

i WANT IT NOW!!, nice review Ben, makes me wanna play it :D
i wanna buy it.. but i have so many games i should finish before this..
good review, but I would have given it higher. One of the best games of this gen. The only disappointment for the game is the graphics, and that is minor anyway, with some slight lines and stuff around some edges. They could have included an easier difficulty as some people may be unable to complete it.. however I loved the difficulty.

it is hard.. the English-Chinese version is the one I have.
not unbearably hard, just requires patience.
this is the ultimate hardcore RPG and with some cones and metal it goes down a treat.
Awesome review and i feel the exact same. Not sure if this happened to anyone else but after i killed Phalanx, the framerate dropped so much its not funny and was lagging like hell. When i went back to the Nexus it was good again
I really want this, but I'm sorta holding back because I get frustrated
easily...
sounds like my type of game :D but i haz no moneys/timez
good review thinking about getting the game
Nice review. Not saying i agree on the score. Will put up a review when i get the time :)
makes me wish i didn't sell it, very enjoyable game.
Oh I am so getting this, I can fight the same monster hundreds of times and I need a new game.
Upon reading this again, i found 2 typos :S Maybe MMGN should be looking for 3 reviewers :P
Great review Ben, im still thinking whether I should get this :)
yeah eb didnt have it today so i ordered it. hopedully have my copy by the weekend
got my copy from eb this morning. 77 bucks
pff old news. was playing this in Oct 2009

Morgan1219 said: Upon reading this again, i found 2 typos


not everyone is perfect :P lol
Shame you guys had to wait A YEAR for it to come down under.
i got my copy for like $80 in 2008..

don't be too scared of this game, the difficulty is worth persevering through!!
Cheapest place to get the black phantom edition anyone? I'm planning to get this :D

saiko said: Cheapest place to get the black phantom edition anyone? I'm planning to get this


I got mine from here but they are sold out.

cgi.ebay.com.au/...

I would assume that they would be getting more in, may not though seeing as its a limited/collectors edition. I had a hard time finding a copy a week ago.
great review, but my favorite line from a review about this game is by Yahtzee, "**** you Demon's Souls! A challenge is one thing but trying to break down a cement wall with your forehead isn't a challenge, it's grounds for getting sectioned. Although I suppose succeeding in breaking down the wall will give you a great sense of accomplishment, which is just as well because you would have lost all your other senses".

A bit long for a quote but it still hits the nail on the head for how hard it is to beat the game. I myself have done it twice. :P [Derp]
Is this harder than Ninja Gaiden 2? :E
After reading through the comments, I seriously can't understand why some people are whinging about the game being hard.

Yes, after you make a mistake, unlike other games, DS doesn't pat your back and say, 'Hey don't worry, here, just try it all over again 100001th time just that jump you failed to land, and here's some extra health packs and ammo for you just to make you feel good'.

Back in Sega Megadrive days, we didn't have save games, earlier ones didnt even have a pause function. Every game we played then, we planned out our moves, if we made a mistake we were only left with a couple of more lifepacks to rectify them. We finished whole games, not just levels with only 3 life packs.
Thats what gaming was, and thats where the fun and challenge was.

70% of the games/levels I design, the clients come back crying ohh, please reduce the difficulty, my five year old can't snap the bad guy's neck in one click..... :|

This game is not your usual run in and hack and slash, well you can very well make it your usual hack-n-slash if you can understand the game, or in simpler words, perfect your hack-n-slash timings.

It is not ground breaking tough, its challenging, if you die, its because YOU made a mistake. Having said that, I think I died more from cliff jumping to make worlds into PBWT than I died from any monster/boss.
(cont)

BPing and invasions are different. It gets your adrenaline pumped up everytime you see that red text 'xxx has invaded your game' flashing on your screen.

Thats what the game is all about, challenging and will make you think.
If you want 'one click ownage' games, go try Hello Kitty Online or Farmville.

/end rant. [Shifty]
Graphics deserve a better score than 7.5
The fact I can't pause this game is a bitch.. I need to pause my games.. Especially when I need to feed Alice.. I mean that's retarded.. [Rage]

tonyamanda said: The fact I can't pause this game is a bitch.. I need to pause my games.. Especially when I need to feed Alice.. I mean that's retarded..


I hope you mean the game is retarded not Alice!? [WTF] ;)
Insomnia much?? :E

Matrix6 said:

tonyamanda said: The fact I can't pause this game is a bitch.. I need to pause my games.. Especially when I need to feed Alice.. I mean that's retarded..


I hope you mean the game is retarded not Alice!?
Insomnia much??


Haha nah it's feeding time =D I might be back at 4 or 5am [MOG]
Just as well she's not a Gremlin eating chicken after midnight!! =)


Ummm, I've yet to open my game! @_@

Matrix6 said: Just as well she's not a Gremlin eating chicken after midnight!!
Ummm, I've yet to open my game!


I wanna sell mine or I'll end up breaking my controller ^_^
I'd recommend selling very soon before the sequel hits Asia. Otherwise trade it in at your local gaming store at Frangas! ;)

Matrix6 said: I'd recommend selling very soon before the sequel hits Asia. Otherwise trade it in at your local gaming store at Frangas!


Good idea =D

Matrix6 said: I'd recommend selling very soon before the sequel hits Asia. Otherwise trade it in at your local gaming store at Frangas!



What? What sequel
There's no sequel announcement.

Anyway, i got this game a few weeks ago but only got to pay it this week. OMG it is fantastic. Very brutal but it won't make you pull your hair out. You really do learn from your experiences and it's so satisfy conquering something with the knowledge you're progressing because of your very own ability and skillz.

The game also scares me too :/ it freaks me out in dark places and when there are ambushes. i experience panic attacks often :p

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's Souls
  • Demon's SoulsDemon's Souls Video
  • Demon's SoulsDemon's Souls Video
  • Demon's SoulsDemon's Souls Video

Recently Read

Featured PS3 Content

The Last Of Us: Remastered - Picking it up?

The Last Of Us: Remastered - Picking it up?

4 days ago Polls 4 6
PlayStation at Gamescom: The games to watch

PlayStation at Gamescom: The games to watch

Tano 1 day Articles 2 7
BioWare

BioWare's new IP could be a modern day RPG

Tano 1 day News 0 4
Has the last-gen Assassin's Creed Comet gone Rogue?

Has the last-gen Assassin's Creed Comet gone Rogue?

Gryllis 2 days News 0 5
Assassin

Assassin's Creed Unity TV spot competition winners!

MMGN 2 days News 13 25
PS Plus August freebies announced

PS Plus August freebies announced

Tano 2 days News 2 6
How many digital subscriptions can we handle?

How many digital subscriptions can we handle?

Gryllis 3 days Articles 6 11
Watch Assassin

Watch Assassin's Creed: Unity's Arno save a lady

Gryllis 3 days News 0 4
CoD: Advanced Warfare campaign trailer

CoD: Advanced Warfare campaign trailer

Tano 3 days News 6 9

Community Content

Awesome Gaming Stuff of Tomorrow, Today!

Awesome Gaming Stuff of Tomorrow, Today!

1 day ago Blog 5 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

punk, tsubibo commented on YouPorn is going ahead with its eSports sponsorship plans

punk 4 hours ago
Username

commented on Snowpiercer review

kangle4 5 hours ago
Username

Tano is selling - Gamecube + 8 games

Tano 6 hours ago
Username

Tano just unlocked the Convincing Salesman achievement!

Tano 6 hours ago
Username

commented on YouPorn is going head with its eSports sponsorship plans

espi_band 14 hours ago
Username

MezFunky just unlocked the Chatter Box achievement!

MezFunky 1 day ago
Username

commented on The Simpsons/Family Guy Crossover - Comic Con 2014

MezFunky 1 day ago
Username

Tano shared a story - Awesome Gaming Stuff of Tomorrow, Today!

Tano 1 day ago