Metal Gear Solid HD Collection Review

by Stephen Heller Featured

12 Comments 19 Votes 12080 Views 08/02/2012 Back to Reviews

Not one, but three unforgettable experiences.

The Metal Gear Solid series has gathered a cult following that transcends the simple love of video games. The series has long been renowned for its tactical espionage gameplay, its production values, the intense and expansive story lines and creator Hideo Kojima's ability to create something that is a work of art. With Metal Gear Solid 4 well and truly behind us and Metal Gear Solid 5 currently in the works, we check out the recently released Metal Gear Solid HD Collection to see if these classics have stood the test of time.

What Metal Gear Solid HD Collection Got Right

Engaging stories - It doesn't matter if you have never played Metal Gear Solid before or not, as the HD Collection simply highlights Hideo Kojima's ability to create an engaging story. Despite being eleven years old, Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty still offers one of the most memorable stories in video game history. All three titles present on the HD Collection provide deep and memorable stories that will stay with you long after the end credits roll.

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.
Check out our video review!

Updated controls for Peace Walker - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker is the stand out in the collection. Originally released as a PSP exclusive, the title benefits greatly from an improved control scheme incorporating a second analogue stick. Simple tasks such as sneaking, aiming, shooting and more are far more functional under the scheme. In many ways the HD version is far and beyond the original hand-held version. There is only one way to play Peace Walker, and that is on your PS3 or Xbox 360, not your PSP.

Outstanding visuals - MGS 2 is 11 years old, but thanks to a new coat of paint it still looks outstanding today. However, Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater is the most noticeable with its vast and lush jungle environments benefitting from a HD facelift. Peace Walker is vibrant and exuberant, however due to the fact it was originally a PSP title, the textures can look a little empty at times. Regardless, considering the age of these titles developer Kojima Productions has really delivered something special with this HD collection in terms of visuals.

Still relevant - The best thing about the Metal Gear games is they are still relevant today. Their stories touch on social issues such as global warming, war, poverty and the state of the world, which still hits close to home today. The stories crafted in these three games are ageless, and this HD collection simply proves that without a doubt.

What Metal Gear Solid HD Collection Got Wrong

Controls - Going back to MGS 2 after all these years can be quite a shock to the system. The controls feel almost counter-intuitive, and it is going to take you quite some time to wrap your head around them after playing modern games. Things are a little better in MGS 3: Snake Eater, thanks to finer camera controls and a better viewpoint, however things are pitch perfect when it comes to Peace Walker. The control scheme benefits greatly from the introduction of that second analogue stick, so much so that you wouldn't be able to go back to the PSP version.

Lip Syncing - Not a deal breaker at all, but the lip syncing is definitely below par compared to what modern games feature. Considering the age of these games, it's definitely expected, but we thought it was worth mentioning in the review.

Accessibility - Metal Gear Solid has always been a niche title, thanks to its batshit crazy story lines and tactical espionage gameplay. This HD collection may bring these games out for a new generation, but they are still lacking when it comes to accessibility. You'll either love them or hate them, there is very little middle ground available here.

The Final Verdict

If you're a fan of the Metal Gear series then you don't need to read this review: go and buy this collection now! If you're looking at a chance to enter the series, the HD collection is a perfect place to start. Despite the age, it looks great in HD, and as long as you're willing to re-learn how third-person games are controlled, you'll find not one, but three unforgettable experiences inside.

By Stephen Heller

Meta Gear Solid HD Collection

Platform: PS3 / Xbox
Developer: Kojima Productions
Similar to: Assassin's Creed, Hitman
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Meta Gear Solid HD Collection

Meta Gear Solid HD Collection Meta Gear Solid HD Collection Meta Gear Solid HD Collection Meta Gear Solid HD Collection Meta Gear Solid HD Collection Meta Gear Solid HD Collection Meta Gear Solid HD Collection

Metal Gear Solid HD Collection Review Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Controls yes they are hard
"Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty still offers one of the most memorable stories in video game history"

Really? i kinda thought Hideo lost his way with this one after the groundbreaking original title in the MGS series. Playing through the Tanker section again in HD has had me wondering what i found so epic about it back in the day? The next section improves things but playing as Raiden in a fairly confined area? some epic bosses though but overall the plot is laughably bad and fairly uninteresting.
Never played the other two, will get round to that soon.
After experiencing MGS4, I was waiting for something like this collection to turn up.
BTW good review Heller.
Can't wait for this to get here.. though I'm gutted they didn't remake the first PS MGS.. that was my favorite by far.
MGS2 is one of my faves though it is the first one I really played properly
I wouldn't mind getting that at all. looks really good and that makes me want to actually buy the Vita when they release it for Vita. The controls are pretty bad for MGS2 compared to todays but still great games.
Getting a PS3 today, and I've never played a MGS game before.
I'm really desperate to play MGS4, but from what I've heard you need to play all the games before it to understand what's going on, so I'm pretty desperate for this as well.
It's not necessary, but you certainly would appreciate it a lot more if you could play through them all.

MGS 1 is still my favourite, where is my HD remake of that baby?
My CQB skills are x10 better than Snake/Big Boss because I play CoD [MOG]
Yeah MGS1 is the best.
The only think i didn't like about part 3 was the radar. They changed it from being able to see your ememy and their sites, to just knowing how far away they are. Love the ending though. Tied in so perfectly.
Have to really disagree with the what it got wrong part. You can't compare the Lip Syncing to today's games considering these are old games up scaled, not remade. Same goes with the controls.
^ Agreed, because it's like saying (re-reviewing now) Leisure Suit Larry of the 1980's had graphics that were too pixelated.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD Collection
  • Meta Gear Solid HD CollectionMeta Gear Solid HD Collection Video
  • Meta Gear Solid HD CollectionMeta Gear Solid HD Collection Video
  • Meta Gear Solid HD CollectionMeta Gear Solid HD Collection Video

Recently Read

Featured PS3 Content

Destiny - Which platform?

Destiny - Which platform?

10/09/2014 Polls 0 3
Shangri-La rules: Far Cry 4 steps up the insanity

Shangri-La rules: Far Cry 4 steps up the insanity

Gryllis 1 day Articles 0 3
PES 2015 trailer takes it right up to FIFA 15

PES 2015 trailer takes it right up to FIFA 15

Tano 1 day News 3 4
Silent Hills looks horrifying

Silent Hills looks horrifying

Tano 1 day News 5 10
Metal Gear Collection 2014 revealed, but it

Metal Gear Collection 2014 revealed, but it's not what you expected

Tano 1 day News 4 8
Destiny proves popular with gamers, making US $325m

Destiny proves popular with gamers, making US $325m

Gryllis 2 days News 0 6
Watch The Evil Within
Gryllis 2 days News 2 5
ZiNG Pop Culture Stores open around Australia

ZiNG Pop Culture Stores open around Australia

Leasha 2 days News 11 11
Watch Dogs’ Bad Blood DLC is worth hacking into

Watch Dogs’ Bad Blood DLC is worth hacking into

Gryllis 3 days Articles 1 7

Community Content

ZiNG Pop Culture Stores open around Australia

ZiNG Pop Culture Stores open around Australia

Leasha 2 days News 11 11
Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

02/09/2014 Blog 10 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

crazynites just unlocked the Socialite achievement!

crazynites 10 hours ago
Username

SBravo just unlocked the Welcomed achievement!

SBravo 11 hours ago
Username

K4ZMA, Matrix6 commented on ZiNG Pop Culture Stores open around Australia

K4ZMA 15 hours ago
Username

commented on PES 2015 trailer takes it right up to FIFA 15

Hugo 1 day ago
Username

commented on Figure Showcase: Phat 1/8 Ryuko Matoi- Senketsu Ver.

DarkJibTEC 1 day ago
Username

punk, Manonit342 commented on The Sims 4 initial impressions pave way for disappointment

punk 1 day ago